Midsomer Murders: The Killings at Badger's Drift | Storyhouse Chester

Based on the book by Caroline Graham and the popular TV series, Midsomer Murders: The Killings at Badger's Drift is embarking on a national tour as part of its world premiere as a play.

Adapted for the stage by Guy Unsworth, we follow DCI Tom Barnaby and Sergeant Gavin Troy who come across some unconventional characters in the picturesque village of Badger's Drift, when well-loved member of the community Emily Simpson is found dead and her friend Lucy refuses to accept it was an accident. From the reaction of the audience upon exiting the theatre, there is no doubt that this play does the TV show justice, however if you're unfamiliar with the TV series (like this reviewer), then you may find yourself questioning the appeal of this show.

That's not to say that there aren't elements to enjoy, as the stunning set design and overall performances from the cast are credible in itself. However, when the show is advertised as a "classic whodunnit that will keep audiences on the edge of their seat", it is a shame when the show falls short with a predictable plot and caricature characters. The tone of the play, whilst attempts to be dark and thrilling, instead becomes subject of absurd comedy, adult humour and nods to the TV series. And whilst this is to be expected to reach the target audience of the show, it does feel alienating to those unfamiliar to it who are instead expecting the thrill of a murder mystery.

The show introduces far too many characters with many of these characters being played by the same actor, and whilst the second act definitely picks up the pace, the first act feels slow and tedious. It's difficult to connect with the characters due to how they've been written, and one struggles to understand the killer's motives and how it all unfolds. However, the cast do well with the material given.

Daniel Casey who starred in the TV series as Sergeant Troy now steps into the role of DCI Barnaby with a measured and assured performance. Alongside him is James Bradwell as Sergeant Troy, and there is a natural connection between the pair that is reminiscent of a work colleague dynamic. Chandrika Chevli and Katherine Lacey do well with their multi-roling of completely different characters, making each one that they play convincing. John Dougal and Rupert Sadler bring humour as mother-son duo with extremely creepy and eccentric personalities.

David Woodhead's set and costume design perfectly creates the sense of an idyllic countryside village filled with eccentric characters. A model village which sits at the back of the stage against a blue sky also illuminates during the night time, giving character to the village created onstage. Alongside this, set changes are effortless to transport us between the harsh lighting of the police station, to personalised homes and gardens. Matt Haskins' lighting design and Ella Wahlstöm's sound design work well together to enhance the atmosphere.

Ultimately, Midsomer Murders: The Killings of Badger's Drift is a love-letter to the popular TV series, and whilst one can appreciate the amount of heart that has been put into its stage adaptation, audiences looking for a gritty edge of your seat murder mystery may end up feeling underwhelmed.

Midsomer Murders: The Killings at Badger's Drift plays at the Storyhouse in Chester until 15th November 2025 before continuing on its national tour.

Tickets and More Information

★★★☆☆ (3*)

Gifted tickets in return for an honest review | Photography by Manuel Harlan